$BA4?H>uBV!'(J

$BIB1!$KO"$l$FMh$kL\0B$r3P$($F$/$@$5$$!#Nc$($PM.;y2J$r$N>I>u$,L5$/$F855$$@$C$?$iFCJL$J<#NE$O$"$j$^$;$s!#IB1!!JFC$K>.;y2J!K$O46@w>I!J$&$D$kIB5$!K$NJu8K$G$9$7!"IB1!$KMh$FB>$NIB5$$r$b$i$C$F5"$k$J$s$F;v$,$h$/$"$j$^$9!#$G$9$+$i!"$`$d$_$KIB1!$KO"$l$FMh$k$N$b9M$(J*$G$9!#(J

$BIB1!$K$9$0O"$l$F9T$+$:$K2H$GMM;R$r8+$kL\0B$O!"(J$B)!5!7y$,$$$$$+!!)"?)M_$,$"$k$+!!)#IaCJDL$jL2$l$k$+(J$B!!$N#3$D$K$J$k$H;W$$$^$9!#$3$N#3$D$,Bg>fIW$J$i$P!"$?$H$((J39$BEY$N9bG.$G$bBg$-$J?4G[$O$"$j$^$;$s!#$?$@$7(J1-2$B%v7n$N@V$A$c$s$O(J38$BEY0J>e$NH/G.$@$1$G$bF~1!4IM}$H$9$k;v$,B?$$$G$9!#$3$l$O@V$A$c$s$KDq93NO$,$J$/=E>I2=$7$d$9$$$+$i$G$9!#(J

$BH/G.!'(J

$B;R6!$OG.$KBP$7$FHf3SE*6/$/!"(J39$BEYBf$N9bG.$G$b7k9=J?5$$K$7$F$$$k;v$,$"$j$^$9!#$h$/!VG.$GF,$,$d$i$l$k!W$H8@$o$l$^$9$,!"(J$BG.$=$N$b$N$,Bg$-$J8e0d>I$r5/$3$9;v$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(J$B8e0d>I$r;D$9IB5$$O!"G.$,0-$$$N$G$O$J$/$FIB5$$,0-$$$N$G$9!J6qBNE*$K$OG>1j!&?qKl1j$J$IF,$NCf$KD>@\%&%$%k%9$d:Y6]$,F~$j9~$`IB5$!"(J15$BJ,$rD6$9D9$$;~4V$N$1$$$l$s$G8F5[$N;_$^$C$?>uBV$d?e$N;v8N$J$IG>$K;@AG$,FO$+$J$$>uBV$J$I!K!#IaDL$NIwl9g$O!"G.$,$G$F$b0l@87|L?2<$2$h$&$H9M$($J$$$G$/$@$5$$!#$?$@$7G.uBV$G(J42$BEY0J>e$NG.$O4m81$J>l9g$,$"$j$^$9$,!"$3$l$O$U$D$&$NIw

$B2rG.:^!'(J

$BG.$OBN$,!V$P$$6]!W$H@o$C$F5/$3$7$F$$$k$b$N$J$N$G!"G.$r2<$2$k$HBN$NDq93NO$,Mn$A$F$7$^$$!"$+$($C$F<#$k$^$G$N;~4V$,D9$/$+$+$j$^$9!#(J$BG.Nd$^$7$NLt$O!V(J38.5$BEY0J>e$G855$$,$J$$!"?)M_$,$J$$$J$IG.$N$?$a$K>uBV$,0-$$$H$-!W$@$1(J$B$G$$$$$G$9!#(J

$B$^$?!">.;y2J$G$O2rG.:nMQ$N6/$$Lt$OA&$a$F$$$^$;$s!#FC$K!V%\%k%?%l%s!W!V%]%s%?!<%k!W$O%$%s%U%k%(%s%6G>>I$NH/>I$K4X78$9$k$H9M$($i$l$F$$$F!";H$&$Y$-$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(J

$BLt6I!&%9!<%Q!<$J$I$GGd$C$F$$$k!VG.Nd$^%7!<%H!W!VNd$(%T%?!W$J$I$N>&IJ$O!"E=$C$F5$;}$ANI$1$l$P;H$C$F$$$F$b$+$^$$$^$;$s$,!"BN29$r2<$2$k8z2L$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(J

$B$1$$$l$s!'(J

$BFMA3$7$?$j%,%/%s%,%/%s$H?L$($?$j$7$F!"GrL\$r$`$$$F8F5[$r;_$a$F4i?'$,@D$/$J$k>uBV$r;W$$Ib$+$Y$F$$$?$@$1$l$P$$$$$G$7$g$&!#>.;y$N$1$$$l$s$NBgH>$,!"G.$=$N$b$N$K$h$k!VG.@-$1$$$l$s!W$G$9!#G.@-$1$$$l$s$OG.$,9b$$$+$i5/$3$k$N$G$O$J$/!"4JC1$K8@$&$HBN

$B$1$$$l$s$,5/$3$C$?$H$-!"7h$7$F8}$NCf$KJ*$r5M$a$?$j$7$J$$$G2<$5$$!#(J$B!V@e$r$+$^$J$$$h$&$K%O%s%+%A$r3z$^$;$k!W$H$$$&$N$O4V0c$$$G$9!#$+$($C$F8}Fb$r=}$D$1$?$j!"3z$^$l$F2x2f$r$7$?$j$7$^$9!#$1$$$l$s$O$[$H$s$I$,(J1$B!A(J2$BJ,!"D9$/$H$b(J5$BJ,0JFb$K<}$^$j$^$9!#(J5$BJ,0J>e;_$^$i$J$$$1$$$l$s$O!"5_5^1j$K$h$k$1$$$l$s$b$"$j!"$^$l$K$OD9;~4V;_$^$i$J$$$b$N$b$"$j$^$9!#=i$a$F$N$1$$$l$s$G$"$l$P!"C;;~4V$G<}$^$C$F$$$F$b4Q;!$N$?$a$KF~1!$K$9$k>l9g$,B?$$$G$9!#(J

$B$*$&EG!&2

$B6&$KBN$+$iI,MW$J?eJ,$,F($2$F$$$/$?$a$K!"C&?e$,?4G[$G$9!#?4G[$JC&?e$NL\0B$O(J$B!V$*$7$C$3$N2s?t$dNL$,>/$J$/$J$$$+!W!V$0$C$?$j$7$F$$$J$$$+!W!V4i?'$,0-$/$J$$$+!W(J$B$"$?$j$G$7$g$&!#EG$-5$$,$"$k$H$-$O?)$Y$?$j0{$s$@$j$9$k$H$^$?EG$$$F$7$^$&$N$G!"?t;~4V?)$Y$?$j0{$s$@$j$;$:$K$*J"$r5Y$^$;$k$H$$$$$G$9!#(J4$B!A(J5$B2s0J>eEG$$$?>l9g$O!"$?$$$F$$$N>l9gE@E)$,I,MW$G$9!#2l9g$O!"2fIW$G$9!#(J

$BJ"DK!'(J

$B!VLUD2!J5^@-Cn?b1j!K$8$c$J$$$G$9$+!)!W$H$$$&?4G[$,B?$$$h$&$G$9$,!"F}MD;y$N5^@-Cn?b1j$O?GCG$,Fq$7$/!";~4V$,$?$?$J$$$HJ,$+$i$J$$>l9g$,B?$$$G$9!#A0F|$h$jDK$$!"DK$/$FJb$1$J$$$H$$$&>l9g$OM5$N$"$kJ"DK$O!"@dBP$K=E>I$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(J

$B$;$-!&SCLD!'(J

$B$;$-$N$?$a$KL2$l$J$$!"?)$Y$?$b$N$rEG$/$H$$$&$N$OHf3SE*>I>u$,6/$$$G$9!#8F5[$KH<$C$F%R%e!<%R%e!<$H$7$?E+$N$h$&$J2;$,J9$3$($k>uBV$O!VSCLD!W$H8@$C$FSCB)H/:n$HF1$8>uBV$G$9$,!";R6!$N>l9g$OSCB)$G$J$/$H$bIw$BSCLD$,$"$C$F2#$K$J$l$J$$!"?)$Y$i$l$J$$!"2qOC$,:$Fq$H$$$&>l9g$O!"LkCf$G$b5_5^$K$$$i$7$F$/$@$5$$!#(J$B5[F~Lt$dE@E)$,I,MW$G$9!#(J

$B!!(J

$B?H6a$J;v8N$H!"$=$NM=KIJT(J

$B;R6!$N;`0x$NBh0l0L!J#0:P;y$r=|$/!K$,!VITN8$N;v8N!W$G$9!JJ?@.(J10$BG/E}7W!K!#(J

$B;v8N$NFbLu$O!")!8rDL;v8N!JLsH>?t!K)"E.?e!JLs#33d!K)#CbB)!JLs#13d!K)$2P:R!&G.=}!J#13d

$B!!(J

$B8rDL;v8N!'(J

9$B:P$^$G$G05E]E*$KB?$$$N$O!"Jb9TCf$N;v8N$G$9!#(J

$B!ZCm0UE@![8@MU$GM}2r$G$-$kG/Np$N;R6!$K$O!"F|:"$+$iF;O)$KHt$S=P$7$r$7$J$$$h$&$K8@$$J9$+$;$k!"

$BE.?e!'(J

0$B!A(J1$B:P$N$[$H$s$I$,MaAe$G$NE.?e!"(J5$B:P0J>e$NBgH>$,3$$d@n$G$NE.?e$G$9!#(J

$B;R6!$r;}$D?F$KBP$9$k%"%s%1!<%H$G$O!"Ls#33d$,!VMa<<$G4m81$JL\$K$"$C$?;v$,$"$k!W$HEz$($F$$$^$9!#0l=o$KF~Ma$7$F$$$??F$,$A$g$C$HL\$rN%$7$?$9$-$KE.$l$k!"$H$$$&%1!<%9$,L\N)$A$^$9!#(J

$B!ZCm0UE@![(J$BF}MD;y$N$$$k2HDm$G$OMaAe$K$*Er$r;D$5$J$$!"MaAe$N$U$?$O8|$/$F7x$$$b$N$K$9$k(J$B!">.$5$J;R6!$@$1$GF~Ma$5$;$J$$!"F}MD;y$,>!

$BCbB)!'(J

$B?7@8;y!AF};y4|$O!V$&$DIz$;?2!W$dSREGJ*$K$h$kCbB)!"F};y4|8eH>0J9_$O5$F;0[J*!JFC$KF&N`!"%T!<%J%C%D!K$K$h$kCbB)$,B?$/$_$i$l$^$9!#%T!<%J%C%D$O!">P$C$?$j5c$$$?$j$7$?:]!"$"$k$$$Oh$C$F$$$F5^Ddl9g$,$"$j$^$9!#(J

$B!ZCm0UE@![F}MD;y$O4pK\E*$K$O!V$&$DIz$;?2!W$K$7$J$$!J!V$&$DIz$;?2!W$OCbB)$@$1$G$J$/!"F}MD;yFMA3;`>I8u72!J(JSIDS$B!K$NH/>I$b9b$/$J$j$^$9!K!"(J$B#3:PL$K~$N;R6!$K$OF&N`!&$"$a6L$rM?$($J$$(J$B!">h$jJ*$NCf$GF&N`$r?)$Y$5$;$J$$!"Jb$-$J$,$i!&M7$S$J$,$i$b$N$r?)$Y$5$;$J$$!"D>7B#3(Jcm$B0J2<$N$b$N$r2$+$i(J1m$B0J>e>e$KCV$/!J8}$KF~$kBg$-$5$O:GBg(J32mm$B!K(J

$BG.=}!'(J

$B#1:PH>$^$G$N;R6!$KB?$/!"$[$H$s$I$,5o4V!&Bf=j!&Ma<<$G!"2?$+$K?($C$F5/$3$j$^$9!#(J

$B!Z5o4V$G$NCm0UE@![?)Bn$J$I$G$O%F!<%V%k%/%m%9$O;H$o$J$$!J;R6!$,0z$CD%$C$F>e$NJ*$r$3$\$9!K!"Bg?M$,Jz$C$3$7$?$^$^?);v$r$7$J$$!"%9%H!<%V$J$I$K$O

$B!ZBf=j$G$NCm0UE@![%l%s%8!&%0%j%k$J$I$r;HMQCf$OBf=j$K;R6!$r6a$E$1$J$$!"?)Bn$N>e$NG.$$J*!JFC$K1UBN!K!"%]%C%H!&%8%c!

$B!ZMa<<$G$NCm0UE@![2?$,$"$C$F$b;R6!$r0l?MMa<<$K;D$5$J$$!"J($+$7N)$F$NMaAe$K$O6a$E$1$J$$(J

$B!Z1~5^=hCV![(J$B:GDc(J30$BJ,!"$"$k$$$O0eNE9T0Y$r$BN.?e!"J]Nd:^$J$I$9$0$Ke$+$i$NG.=}$O0aI~$N>e$+$iN.?e$GNd$d$7!"7h$7$F0aI~$rC&$,$;$h$&$H$7$J$$!#G.=}$KBP$9$kL14VNEK!$dCO0h$N8@$$EA$($N<#NE$O9T$o$J$$(J

$B0[J*8m0{$HCfFG!'(J

$B;R6!!JFC$KF}MD;y!K$O

$B!ZCm0UE@![(J$B$B!JFC$KLt!&$?$P$3!&8}9H$J$I$O!"F}MD;y$O!V?)$YJ*!W$H;W$C$F$$$k;v$,$"$j$^$9!K!"3%;.$K$O?e$rF~$l$F$*$+$J$$(J

$B$d$C$+$$$J0[J*$H$7$F$O%Y%S!<%Q%&%@!l9g$O=|5n:$Fq!"CbB);`$N2DG=@-9b$$!K!"%\%?%s7?EECS!J?)F;$K$D$+$($?>l9g!"?t;~4V$G=EEY$NDYag$r$D$/$k!K$J$I$,$"$k(J

$B!Z0[J*$,$N$I$K$D$+$($?;~$N5_5^=hCV![F}MD;y$O5U$5$^$K$7$FGXCf!J8*9C9|$N4V!K$r$?$?$/!"3XF80J>e$O%O%$%`%j%C%RK!!'0l5$$KN>OS$G$_$>$*$A$r%0%C$HDy$a>e$2$k(J

$B!ZFG@-$N6/$$2HDmMQIJ![I:Gr:^!&%H%$%lMQ@v:^!&%Y%s%8%s!&%7%s%J!l9g$O!"

$B8m0{$G:G$bB?$$$N$O$?$P$3!#$?$P$3$K4^$^$l$k%K%3%A%s$OEG$/:nMQ$,$"$k$N$G!"I$K$O$J$j$^$;$s!#(J$B8m0{$7$?$?$P$3$NNL$,(J2cm$B0J2I>u$,$J$1$l$P=hCV$OITMW!#(J$B$?$@$7?e$KMO$1$?%K%3%A%s$O5[<}$,Aa$/!"4m81$G$9!#(J

$BF,It30=}!'(J

$BG/Np$,>.$5$$$[$IBN$KBP$9$kF,$N3d9g$OBg$-$/!"=E?4$,>e$K$"$k$?$aE>$S$d$9$/!"F,$rBG$A$d$9$$!##3:P$^$G$OE>Mn!&E>E]$K$h$k;v8N$,B?$/!"#3:P0J9_$O8rDL;v8N$,B?$$!#(J

$B!ZCm0UE@![#3:P0J2<$N;R6!$OL\$rN%$5$J$$!&.$5$$:"$+$i>hh$;$k$/$;$r$D$1$k!JBg$-$/$J$C$F$+$i$7$D$1$F$b%@%a!"Bg?M$,8+K\$r<($5$J$1$l$P%@%a!K!#(J

$B;v8ND>8e$O855$$G>I>u$,L5$/!"F~1!$9$kI,MW$,L5$$>l9g$G$b(J24$B;~4V0JFb$OMWCm0U!#(J$B0U<1>c32!&$1$$$l$s!&SREG$,$"$l$P5_5^30Mh$rI>u$,$J$1$l$P$^$:?4G[$J$7!#!!!!(J

$BF}MD;y$G$O$^$l$K7Z$$30=}!J$h$A$h$AJb$-$G$NE>E]$J$I!K$G$bF,38Fb=P7l$r5/$3$9$3$H$b$"$j!"$^$?5U$K0U<1>c32!&$1$$$l$s!&SREG$J$I$,$"$C$F$b0lHU$G8e0d>IL5$/2sI|$9$k>l9g$b$"$j$^$9!#=E>I$+$I$&$+$NH=CG$OFq$7$/!"Bg$7$?>I>u$,$J$/$F$b7P2a4Q;!$N$?$a$KF~1!$r4+$a$k>l9g$b$"$j$^$9!#(J

$B!!(J

$B8xN)3Q4[Am9gIB1!(J | $BIB1!35MW(J | $BAH?%?^(J | $B$*CN$i$;(J | $B?GNE2J(J

$B!!(J

$B8xN)3Q4[Am9gIB1!(J
kakuhp@hana.or.jp
$B:G=*99?7F|(J: 2000.1.11